The 90 Percent Claim: What We Know About Deck Collapses
Every spring the same figure goes around: 90 percent of deck collapses are caused by a failure of the ledger board, the piece of lumber that fastens a deck to the house. It appears in trade association material, in manufacturers' advice and in news reports after a collapse.
We went looking for the study behind it. There is no study. There is an engineer's professional judgment, stated as a belief, and a set of injury figures that do not record causes at all. The practical advice that rests on the number is sound anyway, and the reason it is sound is more useful to a homeowner than the statistic.
Where the number comes from
The North American Deck and Railing Association, the industry's trade group, publishes the claim in this form: an estimated 90 percent of deck collapses result from ledger board connection failures.
The estimate traces to Frank Woeste, a professor emeritus at Virginia Tech. In July 2017 the trade journal JLC reported on an article of his. Woeste had been following deck collapses since 2002, when his team at Virginia Tech began load-testing the structural connections of residential and multifamily decks. He wrote that he believed 90 percent of all collapses resulted from failure of the connection between the ledger and the house, and that most of those involved ledgers attached with nails only.
"I believe" is the phrase he used. Woeste is not a casual source. JLC reports that his team's research on ledger connections led to the bolting schedules later adopted into the International Residential Code, the model code Tennessee has adopted for houses. His estimate is the informed judgment of an engineer who has tested these connections since 2002. It is still an estimate.
What the data cannot say
Five years earlier, the same journal's deck editor had made the opposite point under a blunt headline: "We Don't Know What Causes Most Deck Collapses."
Andy Engel wrote in September 2012 that he could find no forensic study of why decks fail. The nearest thing was a 2010 report from a firm called Legacy Services, built on Consumer Product Safety Commission figures. It counted 224,000 people injured nationally on decks and porches from 2003 to 2007, and said nearly 15 percent of those injuries resulted from a structural failure or collapse. Engel noted who produced it: Legacy Services was owned by Michael Beaudry, the executive director of the deck and railing association.
Engel's objection was to what those figures are. The commission's reports come from notes made by emergency room staff. They record who was hurt. They do not record why the structure failed, because no inspector or engineer wrote them. The report itself says it sorted those notes by searching for words such as "collapse" and "gave way." There is no national system that collects the cause of a deck collapse.
One figure in that column needs correcting. It gives the yearly number of injuries from deck failures as 672. The report itself says 33,000 of the 224,000 injuries came from a structural failure or collapse, and its yearly table shows 6,120 in 2003 and 6,360 in 2004. That is more than 6,000 a year, about ten times the figure in the column. The report's count is also wider than decks falling off houses. Of the 6,120 in 2003, 1,760 were railing failures and 280 were stairs.
An earlier JLC article shows how thin the record is. Between August 2004 and December 2005, collapses reported in the news accounted for 225 injuries and one death. One was a third-floor deck in Virginia Beach that fell with 40 wedding guests on it. The association's concern at the time was the number of failures that never reach the news.
Why the advice still holds
If nobody has counted, why trust the ledger warning?
Because the two sources who disagree about the statistic agree about what they see. Engel wrote that when a news report does name a cause, it is usually a ledger attached only with nails. He described photographs of house framing rotted away behind a ledger that was never flashed against water. He added that he had not heard of properly bolted and flashed decks falling off houses.
Woeste, in the earlier article, put the same thing in an engineer's terms: the immediate cause is usually the ledger connection, and the underlying problem is inadequate design, installation and inspection.
The exact percentage is unknown. What both men describe is known, and a homeowner can check for it: nails where bolts should be, and water where flashing should be.
What to look for
The association's homeowner guidance lists what to check where the deck meets the house.
- Fasteners. The ledger should be attached with approved structural screws or bolts. If nail heads are the only hardware visible, the association says to treat the deck as unsafe and have it inspected.
- Enough of them, properly spaced. Too few fasteners is listed as a fault of its own.
- Flashing. There should be flashing that keeps water from getting behind the ledger.
- Rot or cracking in the ledger board.
- A spongy feel, which suggests the wood has taken up moisture.
- Rusted or loose fasteners.
Age matters as well. Engel observed that many of the collapsed decks in the news were older, built when, in his words, the attitude was that "it's only a deck." The association estimates there are more than 60 million decks in the United States and that 30 million of them are past their useful life.
The association recommends a professional inspection of the whole structure every year, with the homeowner's own look in between.
The Tennessee question
Who inspects a new deck in Tennessee depends on where the house is.
The State Fire Marshal's Office has adopted the 2018 edition of the International Residential Code, with amendments. Its residential program applies to one- and two-family dwellings in parts of the state that do not run their own code enforcement, and its published guidance says the regulations cover new construction and, since October 1, 2011, additions over 30 square feet. Many cities and counties enforce their own codes under an exemption from the state. Some counties and municipalities have opted out of the statewide standards for houses altogether.
For a homeowner that comes down to one phone call before the work starts. Ask the local building department, or the State Fire Marshal's Office if there is none, three questions:
- Does this deck need a permit here?
- Which code edition applies?
- Who will inspect the ledger connection before it is covered up?
That last question is the one this whole article points to. The connection that matters most is the one nobody can see once the deck boards are down.
This article is general information. It is not engineering or legal advice. A deck that shows any of the signs above should be looked at by a qualified inspector or a licensed contractor before it carries a crowd.
Sources
- North American Deck and Railing Association: Deck safety and why decks fail
- North American Deck and Railing Association: How ledger boards impact deck safety
- JLC: Nailed Ledgers the Cause of Most Deck Collapses (2017)
- JLC: We Don't Know What Causes Most Deck Collapses (2012)
- JLC: Deck Check
- Legacy Services: Outdoor Deck and Porch Injury Study (2010)
- Tennessee State Fire Marshal's Office: Residential Permits
- Tennessee State Fire Marshal's Office: Residential Permit FAQs
- Tennessee State Fire Marshal's Office: Opt-out and non-code jurisdictions